Skip to main content
open Book Now
Reminder
The personal information collected is solely used for serving booking reminders. Please visit our privacy policy page to contact us to review or delete data collected.

  • Cancel
  • Lowest Rate Guarantee
  • Late Check Out - 1 PM
  • Free Wi-Fi
  • Complimentary Breakfast
  • The Evelyn Hotel, New York Reviews

New York City Loves
The Evelyn Hotel

Critics have loved our hotel in Manhattan's NoMad neighborhood since opening day, but our guests are what matters most. Read reviews from guests who have stayed at and loved The Evelyn and get inspired to plan your own escape.
By submitting this review you agree that your personal information will be made public.

Select a Rating:

- Required
- Required
- Required
- Required

Tell us more about your stay

Service
Quality
Cleanliness
 
  Guest   •   January 16, 2019

The Evelyn

My sons and I loved our room, the staff were friendly and helpful, with great suggestions on what we could do during our visit. Loved the hotel lobby and bar, beautiful decor. Will definitely stay here during our next visit
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
  Guest   •   January 16, 2019

Comfortable stay

The hotel lobby, rooms, and hallways all have elegant retro decor, which provides a great atmosphere for a getaway. The room was quiet and comfortable despite it's prime location in Flat Iron amid the hustle and bustle of the city The bathroom was especially adorable
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
  Guest   •   January 15, 2019

Great hotel. Great service ...

Great hotel. Great service by the bellhops and the staff. Small but really nice rooms. Also the front desk gave us free coupons for tea, coffee and snacks at the cafe downstairs. Only problem i had was the shower was really hard to adjust to a warm temperature. But other than that great experience. Definitely would stay again
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
  Guest   •   January 15, 2019

Great little spot near the Shake Shack!

Frankly, I booked this hotel on a Black Friday special and got an outrageous deal. The room was pretty small, but functional (lots of USB ports!), and very comfortable. You have to go down to the lobby early morning for coffee, but you also get some nice pastries! The property itself is very attractive and they use a theater/music theme throughout, including some beautiful tile work in the shower! The big selling point is the location. You are very near the 28th Street subway station, close to a Smith's, and a short block from the Madison Square Shake Shack. This also puts you about mid-way from Midtown and The Village. Staff is wonderful and very helpful. A side-tip (could be plus or minus) is the Museum of Sex is on the corner
Service
Quality
Cleanliness
previous
Back to top